Massachusetts Cop Forum banner
1 - 1 of 1 Posts

MassCops Angel
121,497 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
Some Inmates Wear GPS Bracelets During House Arrests

BOSTON -- The state's highest court on Friday upheld the right of county sheriffs to allow certain inmates to serve portions of their sentences at home wearing GPS monitoring devices, rebuffing a judge who said such powers intruded on the judiciary's authority.

The Supreme Judicial Court decision came in the case of Edward Donohue, a man sentenced to serve 18 months for his third drunken driving offense.

Middlesex County Sheriff James DiPaola's office released him from the Billerica House of Correction in September 2007 after he had served about six months, and said he could serve the rest of his sentence under home confinement while wearing a global position satellite bracelet to track his location.
Donohue was required to attend Alcoholics Anonymous and Narcotics Anonymous meetings, attend a weekly class at a counseling center and perform weekly community service.

When Donohue went to court to request a lawyer for his appeal, Judge Diane Kottmyer told DiPaola he did not have the authority to declare Donohue's personal residence a "place of confinement."

The judge ordered DiPaola to confine Donohue in the Billerica House of Correction. She also ordered the sheriff to return to the House of Correction any other defendants who had been released into the GPS program before completing sentences imposed by a judge.

The SJC overturned Kottmyer's ruling, saying that once a judge sentences a defendant, the sheriff controls the conditions of his incarceration.

State law "does not mandate that the sheriff physically confine all offenders within the four walls of the house of correction for the entire length of the 'committed' portions of their sentences," Justice Francis Spina wrote for the majority in the 6-1 decision.

"To the contrary, the statutory scheme confers on the sheriff the authority to permit certain eligible inmates to participate in a variety of programs outside the correctional facility."

In a dissent, Justice Judith Cowin said state laws assume that an inmate taking part in an education, training or employment programs outside a correctional facility will continue to be housed in a facility while participating in the program.

"The GPS program, by releasing a committed offender into his own home, thus exceeds the sheriff's authority under governing law," Cowin wrote.

Attorneys who represented the sheriff's office declined immediate comment. Randall Ravitz, an assistant attorney general who represented the Superior Court Department, also declined immediate comment.
1 - 1 of 1 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.