MassCops - Massachusetts Law Enforcement Network, A Mass Police Web Portal

Massachusetts Law Enforcement Network

Massachusetts Police News, Information and Discussions on MassCops



Pages: 1

Main Page

off duty gun

(Click here to view the original thread on the MassCops Message Board)


Posted by: badge14

Im going to buy one soon. any sugesions?



Posted by: Wolfman

Yeah...more information on its intended use, size, caliber etc. And a spell-check.



Posted by: badge14

I am just looking at something small that is easily concealed



Posted by: Delta784

I swear by my Glock 26.



Posted by: justanotherparatrooper

I love my glock 27...same size 40 cal



Posted by: Delta784

Quote:
Originally Posted by justanotherparatrooper
I love my glock 27...same size 40 cal
I got the 26 when we still had 9mm's; I was just too cheap to get the 27 when we went to 40's.



Posted by: SOT

I vote for the NAA guns or the Kel-tec
http://www.naaminis.com/32NAA.html

http://www.kel-tec-cnc.com/products.html



Posted by: BB-59

My personal choice is the S&W airweight .38 special with a 2 inch barrel.

Very light, 5 rounds of +P sjhp, and the basic malfunction drill is pull the trigger again. Also being stainless requires less maintenance. I usually carry 1 HKS speedloader.



Posted by: PaulKersey

Quote:
Originally Posted by BB-59
My personal choice is the S&W airweight .38 special with a 2 inch barrel. Very light, 5 rounds of +P sjhp, and the basic malfunction drill is pull the trigger again. Also being stainless requires less maintenance. I usually carry 1 HKS speedloader.
I agree. I have the shrouded hammer model. I also have a Keltec p11, but prefer the S&W.

I originally started out swinging an old sock filled with two rolls of quarters, but I needed a little more reach.



Posted by: Wolfman

S&W 638 Airweight. 5 +P JHP's in a lightweight J frame and it won't jam on you. Just what the doctor ordered.



Posted by: OutOfManyOne





Posted by: Barbrady

Sig Sauer P-232 .380

Quote:
Originally Posted by SOT
That NAA is sharp.



Posted by: KozmoKramer

Take a look at the Walther PPK 380 and Sig 232.
I'm partial to Sig, but I know a lot of you folks think they're over-priced.



Posted by: Sniper

Good luck with an NAA........ Been down that road and ended up buying a Seakamp. My off duty carry of choice is UNDOUBTEDLY my Glock 27, with Black Talon ammo !!!!! Weeeeeeeee



Posted by: Barbrady

Quote:
Originally Posted by Sniper
Good luck with an NAA........ Been down that road and ended up buying a Seakamp. My off duty carry of choice is UNDOUBTEDLY my Glock 27, with Black Talon ammo !!!!! Weeeeeeeee
Yeah, I hear nothing compares to Seecamp.



Posted by: Trifecta

S&W MP40 Mini



Posted by: Delta784

Quote:
Originally Posted by Wolfman
S&W 638 Airweight. 5 +P JHP's in a lightweight J frame and it won't jam on you. Just what the doctor ordered.
I used to carry a J-frame S&W, but in today's climate I want something I can go on the offensive with if need be, like if some spoiled brat kid decides to start shooting up a shopping mall.

The Glock has infinitely better sights, 12 round capacity (with the +2 floorplate), and is much more accurate.



Posted by: SOT

Hey I think we had this discussion before...I too like the S&W airweight "belly gun" with the partially concealed hammer....the seecamp is a great one too.
In the winter you can conceal more....So I think the DE is prolly about right for this time of the year....props to you oomo.....which if you say it fast sounds like homo.



Posted by: justanotherparatrooper

I used to carry a J-frame S&W, but in today's climate I want something I can go on the offensive with if need be, like if some spoiled brat kid decides to start shooting up a shopping mall.

....like that ever happens



Posted by: Q5-TPR

Hi all, yes, I am home on my mid tour 2 week leave. My off duty is a Kimber Pro-Carry II. I swear by the .45. I'm a bigger guy (taller not wider) so I have no problem concealing it. 8 rounds of Corbon +P 185 grain all the way. Just my choice, you have to go with what is comfortable for YOU.



Posted by: Killjoy

Quote:
Im going to buy one soon. any sugesions?
Asking that is like asking what kind of shoes to buy. Hint : Go out a try a few out before you buy, I've seen many officers buy some nickel-plated monstrosity because they saw it on TV, and find out its completely wrong for concealed carry!

Some guys are content with a little pocket auto like the .32 Seecamp or NAA...I'm not one of them...I think a .25 or .32 is marginally better than carrying nothing and slightly less effective than carrying a good knife.

I believe you should carry a pistol that chambers a round that will be at least somewhat effective with an off-center hit i.e. a .38 Special or .380 Auto.

Some believe you should carry as similar a pistol that your department issues and trains you with, chambering the exact same round, and there is some wisdom to that. If you don't plan to practice very much, this might be the route for you.

Like my clothing, I "carry for the weather". In the summer months I carry a S&W 649 Lightweight Bodyguard in .38 +P, with a spare speed strip of ammo as well. In the cooler months, I lean towards either my Kahr K9 in 9mm or my Colt Officer's model in .45 ACP, both with a spare mag.

Hope this helps.



Posted by: justanotherparatrooper

good advice KJ, Ive seen a man take a point blank shot to the chest with a .25. He beat the livin snot out of the woman that shot him. The bullet(was ball type) was stopped by his sterum.He had a trip to the hospital to make sure there were no bone fragments inside and was sent home. Im a huge believer in "the bigger is better" ....placed in the right spot.



Posted by: screamineagle

I've never had a problem concealing either my sig 229 or my glock 23.



Posted by: RodneyFarva

if you can find one, H&K Usp Compact. the best gun under the sun.. IMHO





Posted by: TacEntry

The Smith & Wesson 340PD is awesome. Small, light .357, packs a vicious wallop. Not a joy to go to the range with, but fits the bill for maximum firepower in a small and VERY light package. A little pricey, but worth it IMHO.





Posted by: honor12900

Quote:
Originally Posted by screamineagle
I've never had a problem concealing either my sig 229 or my glock 23.
I have trouble concealing my sig 229 and only carry it in winter months. I am also looking for something else. I like SOT's choices here.



Posted by: Nightstalker

m&p 40c - under $500



Posted by: Irish Wampanoag

Off Duty

Bulky is my Sig P229 40 with laser sight from lasermax. Would love to have it for my duty weapon.

Nonbulky is my Seecamp 32c with pocket slipper laser sight. It fits in my front pocket like a wallet.



Posted by: Barbrady

Quote:
Originally Posted by Irish Wampanoag
Nonbulky is my Seecamp 32c with pocket slipper laser sight. It fits in my front pocket like a wallet.
I want one, but, it is one pricey little thing.



Posted by: pahapoika

Quote:
Originally Posted by TacEntry
The Smith & Wesson 340PD is awesome. Small, light .357, packs a vicious wallop. Not a joy to go to the range with, but fits the bill for maximum firepower in a small and VERY light package. A little pricey, but worth it IMHO.

have been looking at those. how are you carrying it ? front pocket , inside the waistband.........

and is it concealable with light clothing ?
</IMG>



Posted by: Killjoy

Quote:
have been looking at those. how are you carrying it ? front pocket , inside the waistband.........

and is it concealable with light clothing ?
I carry the similiar-sized S&W Lightweight Bodyguard in .38 in a Desantis Speed Scabbard under an untucked t-shirt in the summer with no problems. Occasionally I'll carry it in a pocket holster.



Posted by: JMB1977

glock 27 is the only way to go



Posted by: Kem25

I like the Glock 27 and I use an inside the pants holster. Duty weapon is a Glock 22. On a side note: Does anybodies department policy state what somebody can carry off duty? I read ours the other day and it states that the preferred weapon to carry off duty is the duty weapon.



Posted by: id1811xecj

Quote:
Originally Posted by Kem25
On a side note: Does anybodies department policy state what somebody can carry off duty? I read ours the other day and it states that the preferred weapon to carry off duty is the duty weapon.
We have one list for on and off duty. It has a bunch of J frame variants and the Glock 26 plus the larger pistols.



Posted by: Delta784

Quote:
Originally Posted by Kem25
On a side note: Does anybodies department policy state what somebody can carry off duty? I read ours the other day and it states that the preferred weapon to carry off duty is the duty weapon.
We can carry whatever we want, provided it's approved by the chief's office and we demonstrate proficiency with it. I don't think anyone has been denied, but then again I believe every request has been reasonable (no .500 S&W Magnums yet).



Posted by: Killjoy

Quote:
On a side note: Does anybodies department policy state what somebody can carry off duty? I read ours the other day and it states that the preferred weapon to carry off duty is the duty weapon.
Legally, as long is the gun is legally owned and carried, a department could no more limit what you carry off duty then tell you what kind of car to drive or shoes to wear. You are issued a Class A LTC "For All Lawful Purposes", it doesn't say "For All Lawful Purposes with Duty Pistol".

Departments like to set up policies or regulations as to what you are supposed to carry off duty, but it is more of legal smokescreen to shield them from liability than anything else. Unless the department 1. Issued you an off-duty carry piece, and 2. Provided you with the training and ammunition, I would say they have no legal leg to stand on to tell you to do anything.

In the past, many departments had "mandatory armed" policies, which stated that their personnel must be armed 24/7, unless they had some reason not to be armed. This has mostly gone by the wayside as departments became lazy and cheap about training and sacrificed officer-readiness to the altar of liability. In answer to your question; my department has the same absurd policy stating they they would "prefer" that we used our duty pistol, off duty, if we decide to carry off the clock. HA....I love my Sig 226 but its about as convenient to carry as a .44 Magnum Blackhawk.



Posted by: mpd61

I don't wanna say anything...until this gets up to about six or eight pages



Posted by: Delta784

Quote:
Originally Posted by Killjoy
Departments like to set up policies or regulations as to what you are supposed to carry off duty, but it is more of legal smokescreen to shield them from liability than anything else.
I think that would work in your favor if anything; "Here is the form signed by my police chief authorizing me to carry this weapon". That could very well shift any liability back on them.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Killjoy
Unless the department 1. Issued you an off-duty carry piece, and 2. Provided you with the training and ammunition, I would say they have no legal leg to stand on to tell you to do anything.

In the past, many departments had "mandatory armed" policies, which stated that their personnel must be armed 24/7, unless they had some reason not to be armed. This has mostly gone by the wayside as departments became lazy and cheap about training and sacrificed officer-readiness to the altar of liability.
One of my father's friends was MSP, and WAY back in the day they apparently did just that; mandatory 24/7 carrying and issued a Walther PPK/S in .380 for off-duty carry. I remember him showing it to me when he was over the house one night, and he wasn't too thrilled with having to carry it. This was back around 1975 or so.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Killjoy
In answer to your question; my department has the same absurd policy stating they they would "prefer" that we used our duty pistol, off duty, if we decide to carry off the clock. HA....I love my Sig 226 but its about as convenient to carry as a .44 Magnum Blackhawk.
I'm less enamored of the P226 than you, but I fully concur with your opinion of its concealment capabilities. I unintentionally let my LTC lapse for a couple of months many years ago, and had to carry that behemoth off-duty until the renewal came in. It wasn't easy or fun.



Posted by: TacEntry

Quote:
Originally Posted by pahapoika
have been looking at those. how are you carrying it ? front pocket , inside the waistband.........

and is it concealable with light clothing ?
</IMG>
Yes & Yes. In the summer I've carried it in a belly band with t-shirt and gym shorts and have all but forgotten about it. I think the rounds weigh more than the the gun! VERY LIGHT but Not for the timid when fired - It throws about a 12 inch flame when you fire it & feels like your being hit in the arm with a steel pipe every time you pull the trigger - It's GREAT! It's very clear what this little monster was designed to do...





Posted by: jgreen902

[IMG]file:///C:/DOCUME%7E1/Jesse/LOCALS%7E1/Temp/moz-screenshot.jpg[/IMG]Check out the new Walther PPS, it's very small and comes in 9mm and (soon) .40 caliber. I've read some reviews on it and it sounds great. You can hold anywhere from 5-8 rounds in it, depending on the magazine size and caliber.



Posted by: id1811xecj

We also have to qualify with out off duty weapon on the same qual course quarterly. Not impossible but a J frame at 25 yards is no fun. We used to shoot at 50. That would ahve been a long way,.



Posted by: PaulKersey

Quote:
Originally Posted by Killjoy
Departments like to set up policies or regulations as to what you are supposed to carry off duty, but it is more of legal smokescreen to shield them from liability than anything else. Unless the department 1. Issued you an off-duty carry piece, and 2. Provided you with the training and ammunition, I would say they have no legal leg to stand on to tell you to do anything. .
Here's the angle some of the Chiefs, Commissioners use;

If you activate yourself as a police officer, and fire your weapon off duty, we will back you {Liability, defence atty. etc. just as if working} as long as it's with a dept. authorized weapon.

You can carry and shoot what you want, but if not a dept. authorized weapon, you're on your own, because the weapon was not authorized.

If you save the day, you're a hero, regardless of what weapon you used. If you hit an innocent bystander, you'd better hope it was with a dept. authorized weapon, or you're on your own.

The department heads know that it's pretty easy to gain compliance this way, as they assume, the first thing you will be doing before, or after a
shooting, is waiving your badge.



Posted by: Barbrady

Quote:
Originally Posted by PaulKersey
Here's the angle some of the Chiefs, Commissioners use;
If you activate yourself as a police officer, and fire your weapon off duty, we will back you {Liability, defence atty. etc. just as if working} as long as it's with a dept. authorized weapon.
Mine is same, though, we can carry what ever we want...just have to qualify with it.



Posted by: Motor23

1.) Assess your risk factors.., what is your mindset while off duty, have you had a recent encounter with an "old customer" and do you frequent areas which may bring you in contact with a criminal element?. These are all the fundamentals but recently events have come into light that have occurred in safe zones (schools, shopping malls, etc) so apparently there are no longer any safe zones take this into consideration.
2.) OD weapon considerations.., "rather have and not need than need and not have" in a shooting situation there is no adequate replacement for a firearm. As one successful hunter was quoted "I always make sure to bring enough gun". Most experts agree that the minimum in OD carry would be a 9mm or .38 spec some even promote the fact that bigger is better this is a point to consider.
3.) How, why, what, when and where. being as a familiar with your OD weapon as your duty weapon. A number of officers have opted to purchase a smaller version of their issued duty weapon and this approach makes a lot of sense. Always carry the weapon in the same place, always bring spare ammo, and understand that while OD you should be in an avoidance mode especially when with family or as they would say non combatants. USE COMMON SENSE.
4.) Train and practice.., if you have purchased a new holster that you are a little unfamiliar with then practice all weapon handling skills with it while it is UNLOADED. We are going to attempt to run some OD carry training sessions in the future that integrate survival tactics with firearms and DT (real world situations) we will keep you informed. But firearms safety is the #1 consideration. Accidents happen and remember "bullets have NO discipline"
5.) Add’l equipment.., your official Police ID w/badge, cell phone, informing the non combatants that you maybe with what to do if the situation goes south, etc. One PO involved in recent OD shooting situation out of state resigned himself to seeking a position of cover and relaying information about shooter to his dispatcher until uniformed officers arrived. His thoughts were that he was outgunned small semi auto vs. large caliber weapon, he could not engage the suspect without a high probability of inflicting non collateral damage to civilians in area and most importantly sticking to a predesignated plan that he had formulated if involved in a OD deadly threat situation. I would have to give him "star of the day" for this one and his actions but I am also sure he was Monday morning by some of the experts who were not there. Learn from others
6.) Final Notes.., be reasonable and be realistic.., take an approach that will work for you and lastly remember "there are no safe zones




Posted by: Eamonn Wright

Most of the year, I carry a SIG 228 off duty in a Sparks VMII IWB holster. In the VMII, it's very easy to conceal, and comfortable as well. In the winter, I usually carry a Colt Combat Commander with a spare mag, in an owb holster.
Hydro-shocks in the Colt, Black Talons in the 228.



Posted by: HEATMS

Springfield Armory Subcompact Xd 40 Cal. Thats What I Use



Posted by: mpd61

Okay here I go;

1. Walther P-22
2. J-frame Smith snub .38/357
3 K-frame Smith 3" .357
4. Glock 26/27
5. Colt M1911 type
6. N-frame .41/44/45

Whatever you carry, you must have a secure quality holster, practice, and be able to draw, fire and hit a 6" circle at 7 yards in under 3-4 seconds. Thats if your serious about off-duty carry. If you're a recreational CCW person, you should at least have the right holster, and be familiar with your gun and practice with it



Posted by: semiunmarked

S&W J Frame 642 in .38

S&W 3913 in 9mm

Para-Ordnance LDA 7.45 in .45 (a fantastic piece but a PIA to strip & clean)

A Glock 27 in .40 may be in the near future as well.



Posted by: justanotherparatrooper

Quote:
Originally Posted by mpd61
Okay here I go;

1. Walther P-22
2. J-frame Smith snub .38/357
3 K-frame Smith 3" .357
4. Glock 26/27
5. Colt M1911 type
6. N-frame .41/44/45

Whatever you carry, you must have a secure quality holster, practice, and be able to draw, fire and hit a 6" circle at 7 yards in under 3-4 seconds. Thats if your serious about off-duty carry. If you're a recreational CCW person, you should at least have the right holster, and be familiar with your gun and practice with it
....and thats just what he carries off duty!



Posted by: Belker

I swear by the glock 27 (40 cal. S&W) It is very accurate, and pretty easy to conceal even in the summer.



Posted by: Q5-TPR

My off duty! Finally got it to load!



Posted by: bcibob670

Quote:
Originally Posted by Motor23
1.) Assess your risk factors........ 2.) OD weapon considerations............3.) How, why, what, when and where. being as a familiar with your OD weapon as your duty weapon.............. you should be in an avoidance mode especially when with family or as they would say non combatants. USE COMMON SENSE......... 4.) Train and Practice...............................
5.) Add’l equipment.., your official Police ID w/badge, cell phone, informing the non combatants that you maybe with what to do if the situation goes south, etc. One PO involved in recent OD shooting situation out of state resigned himself to seeking a position of cover and relaying information about shooter to his dispatcher until uniformed officers arrived. His thoughts were that he was out gunned small semi auto vs. large caliber weapon, he could not engage the suspect without a high probability of inflicting non collateral damage to civilians in area and most importantly sticking to a predesignated plan that he had formulated if involved in a OD deadly threat situation. I would have to give him "star of the day" for this one and his actions but I am also sure he was Monday morning by some of the experts who were not there. Learn from others
6.) Final Notes.., be reasonable and be realistic.., take an approach that will work for you and lastly remember "there are no safe zones
I have read the whole thread and I like what Motor23 has to say specifically #5.
I see the carry question as not one of only make, model (mine is a S&W sigma 40.) but many other elements as well, like Motor23's post.

If off duty I would like the most bang for the buck so I would go for the Glock .45 compact model 30. At ten rounds it is great quantity and quality for a Concealed Carry. Then again, I have used my cell phone in more off duty situations than my gun or badge. (I got this I look like a cop thing I am told)

Finally the best weapon for Concealed carry is your brain, fully loaded, well trained and able to handle any situation with sober judgment and common sense.






Posted by: mpd61

Quote:
Originally Posted by bcibob670
Finally the best weapon for Concealed carry is your brain, fully loaded, well trained and able to handle any situation with sober judgment and common sense.


You're darned tootin buddy! Here's my only christmas wish list item:



Posted by: Killjoy

Quote:
If off duty I would like the most bang for the buck so I would go for the Glock .45 compact model 30. At ten rounds it is great quantity and quality for a Concealed Carry.
In my opinion, I believe the Glock 30 conceals only slightly better than a red schoolhouse brick. It seems that Glock has never figured out its not just the length or height, its also the width! But to each his own....

Quote:
Finally the best weapon for Concealed carry is your brain, fully loaded, well trained and able to handle any situation with sober judgment and common sense.
Absolutely true...a sharp-eyed man walking around with cellphone can often be far more useful then some dolt with a .44 Magnum.



Posted by: Irish Wampanoag

Motors 23 # 5 would be great if the State Police would answer the call when you use your cell phone. I had them hang up twice on several major accidents on 93/128. And a whole bunch of times they just never answered. Suggestion put all surrounding PD numbers where you work and live in your cell phone. Never the less Motors 23 #5 would be the best choice of action!!!



Posted by: Killjoy

Quote:
Motors 23 # 5 would be great if the State Police would answer the call when you use your cell phone. I had them hang up twice on several major accidents on 93/128. And a whole bunch of times they just never answered. Suggestion put all surrounding PD numbers where you work and live in your cell phone. Never the less Motors 23 #5 would be the best choice of action!!!
Of course you realize if you call a local department with a problem on the highway, they'll probably just forward your call to the state police.

Also, barracks receive hundreds of calls for one accident, so don't just assume they don't know about it. When there is one trooper working the desk, not everyone gets the concierge treatment. I know sometimes when I've received my seventeenth call on the same incident, the party is lucky to get a gruff "Yeah, we know" followed by the dialtone.

By the way...what does this have to do with off-duty guns?



Posted by: HELPMe

Quote:
Originally Posted by SOT
good luck finding a kel-tec in MA. I tried to get one into the state and got bitched. The seecamp is the only mass compliant pistol with that is the best mass compliant alternative to the kel-tec p-11



Posted by: Barbrady

Kel-tec is gahbage...IMO.



Posted by: Irish Wampanoag

Quote:
Originally Posted by HELPMe
good luck finding a kel-tec in MA. I tried to get one into the state and got bitched. The seecamp is the only mass compliant pistol with that is the best mass compliant alternative to the kel-tec p-11
That is correct and only the 32c not 380 why??? I have no idea!!!



Posted by: PearlOnyx

I carry a Glock 27 with an inside the pants holster. I've had no problems with that given I wear shorts 12 months out of the year. =) Just gotta buy everything a size bigger. I had a Sig 229 before, but it was a little too bulky and "printed" too much.



Posted by: SOT

Quote:
Originally Posted by HELPMe
good luck finding a kel-tec in MA. I tried to get one into the state and got bitched. The seecamp is the only mass compliant pistol with that is the best mass compliant alternative to the kel-tec p-11
Are you a police officer? Then there is no problem.
We've sent about a dozen of these things out to various departments in the last year or so.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Killjoy
Of course you realize if you call a local department with a problem on the highway, they'll probably just forward your call to the state police.

Also, barracks receive hundreds of calls for one accident, so don't just assume they don't know about it. When there is one trooper working the desk, not everyone gets the concierge treatment. I know sometimes when I've received my seventeenth call on the same incident, the party is lucky to get a gruff "Yeah, we know" followed by the dialtone.

By the way...what does this have to do with off-duty guns?
Nothing just dig on the MSP...again...yo!



Posted by: DonaldB79

My personal firearm is a Glock model 22 (.40 cal) simple yet effective, bullets aren't too tough on the budget either.

I would like to get a Model 27 (.40 cal), just because it is smaller in size. to carry.



Posted by: hacker15

For off-duty, I carry a Springfield 1911 A-1 UC V10 (fully ported 3" Commander model). .45 and super slim (6 + 1), but I have 8 and 10 round mags for it. Carry 2 extra 6 round mags. Figure if I can't stop the threat with 19 rounds of Hornady TAP .45 ACP, I better bring a SWAT squad!



Posted by: JoninNH

I carry a .38 snub in an ankle, or my .40 P94DC Ruger IWB. Ugly gun, but accurate.



Posted by: kttref

I got my girly gun (so I've been told)....glock 26. we have a full qualifying course and although i wanted something smaller, I can't shoot anything smaller from 25 yards out and still pass...so that's that.



Posted by: Tango

[quote=SOT;245250]Are you a police officer? Then there is no problem.
We've sent about a dozen of these things out to various departments in the last year or so.



I got the Kel Tec P3AT last year in Mass., dealer sold it to me with LEO credentials..great little gun



Posted by: Delta784

Quote:
Originally Posted by kttref View Post
I got my girly gun (so I've been told)....glock 26.
Load it with the right ammo and it ain't no girly gun, trust me.



Posted by: kttref

True...



Posted by: DPDM

I've had my eye on this puppy. Although there is the all black stealth model...

Para Ordnance Warthog
10+1 rd .45 ACP
3" Barrel
24 Ounces




Posted by: Killjoy

Quote:
I've had my eye on this puppy. Although there is the all black stealth model...
Don't bother. I owned one, and while it operated fine, it was a bitch to shoot. Two fingers hang off the bottom of the grip and it has a vicious recoil that violently snaps the barrel skyward. Also, the thick frame makes it about as concealable as a cinderblock. Makes shooting my .38 snubby with +P's seem like a day at the park. I own a lightweight Colt Officer's now, and its more concealable and a better shooter.



Posted by: HOLLYROCK50

Might I suggest a Sig P232 .380. Sig is a very reliable weapon and it is very easy to conceal. And wouldn't you know it, I have one for sale.... Check my thread on here. $450/BO.



Posted by: Delta784

Quote:
Originally Posted by HOLLYROCK50 View Post
Might I suggest a Sig P232 .380. Sig is a very reliable weapon and it is very easy to conceal. And wouldn't you know it, I have one for sale.... Check my thread on here. $450/BO.
I don't mean to ruin your sale, but we had HORRIBLE experiences with the SIG P232. They were issued to command staff & detectives, and while easily concealable, they malfunctioned with alarming frequency after a few rounds when they got hot.



Posted by: HOLLYROCK50

Quote:
Originally Posted by Delta784 View Post
I don't mean to ruin your sale, but we had HORRIBLE experiences with the SIG P232. They were issued to command staff & detectives, and while easily concealable, they malfunctioned with alarming frequency after a few rounds when they got hot.

This is not going to help me.... LOL. I haven't had any problems with it thus far. What were some of the problems you had?



Posted by: justanotherparatrooper

Quote:
Originally Posted by HOLLYROCK50 View Post
This is not going to help me.... LOL. I haven't had any problems with it thus far. What were some of the problems you had?
NOt tryin to pile on Hollyrock but my girlfriend had one as well, given to her as a present .....it was VERY ammo sensitive, something that a selfdefense gun should not be.



Posted by: Delta784

Quote:
Originally Posted by HOLLYROCK50 View Post
This is not going to help me.... LOL. I haven't had any problems with it thus far. What were some of the problems you had?
As JAP mentioned, they seemed to be very ammo-sensitive; factory rounds would initially feed flawlessly, but reloads and "off-brand" (Sellier & Belot, Fiocchi, etc.) ammo would jam. After 10-15 rounds when the gun got hot, it would malfunction no matter what type of ammo was used.



Posted by: HOLLYROCK50

JAP feed back is good. Just haven't heard this before. When it got hot, was the slide jamming? I do notice that the slide is very tight even when cold. I stripped it down and used a good lube (stop laughing) on the rails and havent found a problem. As far as ammo, I have never been a fan of cheap ammo so I don't shot it. Because its a .380 I tend to go with Hydra Shock for my carry ammo. I did the MCJTC 50 round qual course with it and had no malfunctions.



Posted by: Nighttrain

S&W Airlight .38 - Just a gut gun really. No worries about jamming with a wheel gun and very light.



Posted by: Motor23

I still like my sig 380.



Posted by: BB-59

I carry a S&W .38 airweight. 5 shots of .38 + P SJHP, malfunction drill, pull trigger again.



Posted by: Barbrady

Quote:
Originally Posted by HOLLYROCK50 View Post
JAP feed back is good. Just haven't heard this before. When it got hot, was the slide jamming? I do notice that the slide is very tight even when cold. I stripped it down and used a good lube (stop laughing) on the rails and havent found a problem. As far as ammo, I have never been a fan of cheap ammo so I don't shot it. Because its a .380 I tend to go with Hydra Shock for my carry ammo. I did the MCJTC 50 round qual course with it and had no malfunctions.
I carry a 232 w/Hydra Shok as well. I too have never had a malfunction. At the range I will usually fire off a box of the cheapest ball money can buy. I will say that I have never used a reload.

It is odd how reviews on a gun can be so different from the next. Kel Tec for example it seems the majority on here had good feedback. My experience was pathetic it jammed catastrophically out of the box on the second magazine. I was using this particular ranges ammo, WinClean..



Posted by: Delta784

Quote:
Originally Posted by HOLLYROCK50 View Post
JAP feed back is good. Just haven't heard this before. When it got hot, was the slide jamming? I do notice that the slide is very tight even when cold. I stripped it down and used a good lube (stop laughing) on the rails and havent found a problem. As far as ammo, I have never been a fan of cheap ammo so I don't shot it. Because its a .380 I tend to go with Hydra Shock for my carry ammo. I did the MCJTC 50 round qual course with it and had no malfunctions.
You must have an exceptionally good one; we had well over twenty, with almost all of them having problems. SIG can make a great gun, I just don't think the P-232 is one of them.

Besides that, I'm not a big fan of the .380 for self-defense use. If you use hot ammo (Cor-Bon) it can be marginal, but I think 9mm/38+P is as low as one should go.



Posted by: Q5-TPR

the minimum number your caliber should start with is 4. Just my opinion.



Posted by: Delta784

Quote:
Originally Posted by Q5-TPR View Post
the minimum number your caliber should start with is 4. Just my opinion.
So a .357 Magnum is no good?



Posted by: Q5-TPR

Quote:
Originally Posted by Delta784 View Post
So a .357 Magnum is no good?
Well, of course there are exceptions to the rule, LOL!



Posted by: Delta784

Quote:
Originally Posted by Q5-TPR View Post
Well, of course there are exceptions to the rule, LOL!
This will ruin the day of anything on two legs;





Posted by: Q5-TPR

Nice Delta, I actually have the 342PD in 38+P. Well that is until my wife decided she liked it more and it is now hers! Now I use the Kahr PM40 as my back up. Still packing the Kimber Pro Carry II for my off duty.



Posted by: Delta784

Quote:
Originally Posted by Q5-TPR View Post
Nice Delta, I actually have the 342PD in 38+P. Well that is until my wife decided she liked it more and it is now hers! Now I use the Kahr PM40 as my back up. Still packing the Kimber Pro Carry II for my off duty.
That's actually not mine, although I wouldn't mind one. Off-duty I carry a Glock 26 with Cor-Bon 115gr JHP (1350fps and 466fpe) rounds; if 13 rounds of that doesn't put someone on their backside, then I'm running the other way.



Posted by: 94c

Quote:
Originally Posted by Q5-TPR View Post
Nice Delta, I actually have the 342PD in 38+P. Well that is until my wife decided she liked it more and it is now hers! Now I use the Kahr PM40 as my back up. Still packing the Kimber Pro Carry II for my off duty.

Just the thought of a gun in my wife's hands stains my shorts.



Posted by: Q5-TPR

My wife has her LTC and does pack every now and then, depending on where she has to go.



Posted by: MARINECOP

I highly reccomend the H&K USP 40 compact. I have had mine since 97 and never had a problem with it. They are very expensive, but well worth it.



Posted by: ninety_four_c

I prefer to carry the glock moodel 27 using an in the pants holster



Posted by: charger

A lot of good ideas, but I dont think so people actually carry everyday is so they must be like Mel Gibson with a shoulder rig and spare mags!!! A lot of the guns they have recommended are big. How do u conceal a 1911 or Glock 22 in a pair of shorts. Anyway good choice and i carry mine everyday all year round. Kahr P series P9 or P 40. And they all so have the Pm9 and Pm40 which are even smaller. You can check them out at Kahr.com. Great quality, small profile, light when loaded, very thin, Good double action trigger, life time warrant. Glock 26 or 27 good choice but they are still a thick gun. Wouldnt go below a 9mm, 32 or 380 have questionable stopping power by most creditable f/a publications or ballistic reports. Keltec questionable reliability also available in many publications. Or you could just go with the old S&W snub nose revolver.



Posted by: Delta784

Quote:
Originally Posted by charger View Post
Or you could just go with the old S&W snub nose revolver.
I love Smith wheelguns, but the days of a snub revolver for most off-duty carry are past. With these days of people treating shopping malls and school campuses as their personal shooting galleries, one should have a handgun powerful enough, accurate enough, and with enough capacity to go on the offensive against an active shooter. That's why I exclusively carry my Glock 26 off-duty, even though I have other options.



Posted by: mpd61

Jeezum Bruce!

Don't give up on old faithful yet brother! Those new Scandium smith's like eight ( shot 357's and 44/45's with speedloaders will keep up with the glocks.




Posted by: justanotherparatrooper

Quote:
Originally Posted by mpd61 View Post
Jeezum Bruce!

Don't give up on old faithful yet brother! Those new Scandium smith's like eight ( shot 357's and 44/45's with speedloaders will keep up with the glocks.
...I love my 329pd (44 mag) but You wont be doin double taps with it unless youve got the wrist of Hercules on the plus side...it wieghs LESS than mu Glock 23.



Posted by: dgove35

glock 27 is an excellent off duty weapon and shoots very well



Posted by: topcop14

Quote:
Originally Posted by Delta784 View Post
I love Smith wheelguns, but the days of a snub revolver for most off-duty carry are past. With these days of people treating shopping malls and school campuses as their personal shooting galleries, one should have a handgun powerful enough, accurate enough, and with enough capacity to go on the offensive against an active shooter. That's why I exclusively carry my Glock 26 off-duty, even though I have other options.
I am with you on this bruce, I am considering buying a Glock 23 to replace my Glock 27 for that very reason. However, I have to admit I still have a soft spot for my S&W 342 Air Weight Ti. 5 rounds of .38+P is better then going un armed and it can be confortably carried no matter what one is wearing.



Posted by: ninety_four_c

Quote:
Originally Posted by charger View Post
A lot of good ideas, but I dont think so people actually carry everyday is so they must be like Mel Gibson with a shoulder rig and spare mags!!! A lot of the guns they have recommended are big. How do u conceal a 1911 or Glock 22 in a pair of shorts. Anyway good choice and i carry mine everyday all year round. Kahr P series P9 or P 40. And they all so have the Pm9 and Pm40 which are even smaller. You can check them out at Kahr.com. Great quality, small profile, light when loaded, very thin, Good double action trigger, life time warrant. Glock 26 or 27 good choice but they are still a thick gun. Wouldnt go below a 9mm, 32 or 380 have questionable stopping power by most creditable f/a publications or ballistic reports. Keltec questionable reliability also available in many publications. Or you could just go with the old S&W snub nose revolver.

I was issued the P40 for UC work and had to qualify with it. Not easy to hit the paper from 15. I also had alot of misfeeds with it. The likely hood of a gunfight from 15 is not realistic in those circumstances. I carry the glock 27 offduty and which is a much better shooting gun. Personally the Kahr is ok if your looking to scare them away with the bang, but the glock is much better for stopping power.



Posted by: charger

Hey 94c I was wondering are you having a hard time hitting targets are 15 feet or 15 yards? Anyway I may have an answer to your accuracy problem, which I had the same problem when I got my first Kahr. Your spoiled with that Glock action trigger pull like the rest of us. The Kahr has a true 9 lbs. trigger pull compared to the two stage 5.5 lbs. trigger pull on the Glock. So basically you just go to practice and you will be shooting them thru the same hole. I was shooting all over the paper and just practiced and shoot good groups at 15 yards. Plus it has a small barrell and is basically designed for in close use. As far as your feed problems, get on the horn with Kahr and they will send u a new barrell. I had the same problem with my p40, but didnt with my P9 which has never had a malfuction in about 4000 round. What did you mean by better stopping power with the Glock, since stopping power is rated by ammuntion not the firearm?



Posted by: mpd61

Quote:
Originally Posted by ninety_four_c View Post
Personally the Kahr is ok if your looking to scare them away with the bang, but the glock is much better for stopping power.
Sure neophyte...
Just keep perpetuating the myths. "stopping power". Make me laugh my hairy-pimpled ass off dude!




Posted by: Killjoy

Quote:
I love Smith wheelguns, but the days of a snub revolver for most off-duty carry are past. With these days of people treating shopping malls and school campuses as their personal shooting galleries, one should have a handgun powerful enough, accurate enough, and with enough capacity to go on the offensive against an active shooter.
I respectfully disagree. You are never going to have enough "firepower" to go head-to-head versus some nut with rifle or a shotgun, unless you walk around dressed like a flasher with shorty AR under your coat. You make up for lack of firepower with surprise, cunning, and good tactics.

The police officer in Utah who helped to stop the active shooter in the mall had a Sig 245 .45 with only seven rounds in it, and no spare magazine. A good pistol, but hardly a match for a shotgun. By ambushing the assailant he was able to pin him down long enough for responding officers to send him to his just reward.

Honestly, even though those of us who carry off-duty would like to think we could stop an active shooter, probably the best we could do against a determined killer with heavy weapons to throw a monkey wrench in the works and slow them down. By putting a couple of rounds in the killers' direction, we can hold him up long enough for the cavalry to arrive with patrol rifles, shotguns and better pistols than ours.

I plan to continue carrying my S&W Bodyguard in .38+P in the warmer weather because it is so damn convenient! Loaded with good hollowpoints and with a spare speed-strip with 6 extra rounds I have eleven shots to give bad guys a hard day. I feel well equipped to stop any potential muggings or carjackings, or other street-level crimes. While I won't say a .38 is my first choice for going against some maniac with a rifle or shotgun, neither is my .45 , .40 or 9mm pistols either! At the very least, I can put a couple of rounds in his flank or at least divert his attention to save some people's live and buy time for the cavalry to arrive. The .38 on your hip is better than the .44 mag you left at home.



Posted by: mpd61

Quote:
Originally Posted by Killjoy View Post
to save some people's live and buy time for the cavalry to arrive. The .38 on your hip is better than the .44 mag you left at home.
You're damn right buddy!



Posted by: Delta784

Quote:
Originally Posted by Killjoy View Post
I respectfully disagree. You are never going to have enough "firepower" to go head-to-head versus some nut with rifle or a shotgun, unless you walk around dressed like a flasher with shorty AR under your coat. You make up for lack of firepower with surprise, cunning, and good tactics.
Agreed, but you need something with enough "oomph" to end the fight once you get the drop on someone.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Killjoy View Post
The police officer in Utah who helped to stop the active shooter in the mall had a Sig 245 .45 with only seven rounds in it, and no spare magazine. A good pistol, but hardly a match for a shotgun. By ambushing the assailant he was able to pin him down long enough for responding officers to send him to his just reward.
My point exactly; a .45 ACP round isn't even in the same stratosphere as a .38 +P fired out of a 1 3/8" barrel.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Killjoy View Post
Honestly, even though those of us who carry off-duty would like to think we could stop an active shooter, probably the best we could do against a determined killer with heavy weapons to throw a monkey wrench in the works and slow them down. By putting a couple of rounds in the killers' direction, we can hold him up long enough for the cavalry to arrive with patrol rifles, shotguns and better pistols than ours.
Once again, agreed; but, I would not feel the least bit comfortable wasting rounds when I only have 5 or 10-11 total and the reload time with a speedloader or speed strip is considerably longer than a magazine change.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Killjoy View Post
I plan to continue carrying my S&W Bodyguard in .38+P in the warmer weather because it is so damn convenient! Loaded with good hollowpoints and with a spare speed-strip with 6 extra rounds I have eleven shots to give bad guys a hard day. I feel well equipped to stop any potential muggings or carjackings, or other street-level crimes. While I won't say a .38 is my first choice for going against some maniac with a rifle or shotgun, neither is my .45 , .40 or 9mm pistols either! At the very least, I can put a couple of rounds in his flank or at least divert his attention to save some people's live and buy time for the cavalry to arrive. The .38 on your hip is better than the .44 mag you left at home.
As I mentioned, I love S&W snub revolvers, but they just don't do it for me anymore. I'm an excellent handgun shot, but putting all 5 shots out of a J-frame Smith (double-action) into the kill zone at 50 feet is an accomplishment under perfect conditions with no stress, never mind in a combat situation. I can reliably put all 13 rounds from my Glock 26 (+2 extender in the magazine) into that area at the same distance with no problem whatsoever.

As with a lot of things in life, to each his own, and any gun beats nothing in a pinch. I just don't feel comfortable with a snubby revolver anymore.



Posted by: mpd61

Quote:
Originally Posted by Delta784 View Post
I just don't feel comfortable with a snubby revolver anymore.
Yeah but I'll bet you could shoot the gonads off a fly at 15 yards with a 4" k-frame .357 you old fart!




Posted by: Delta784

Quote:
Originally Posted by mpd61 View Post
Yeah but I'll bet you could shoot the gonads off a fly at 15 yards with a 4" k-frame .357 you old fart!
A K-frame and 2 1/8" more in barrel length makes all the difference!

And who you calling old??



Posted by: Killjoy

Quote:
Agreed, but you need something with enough "oomph" to end the fight once you get the drop on someone.
A .38+P is hardly a BB gun...I feel confident that a good hit with a 110 grain hollowpoint will inflict some serious damage. While it is not as good as a .45 ACP, pistols designed for the .45 are generally not as concealable or as lightweight as the snubby.

Quote:
Once again, agreed; but, I would not feel the least bit comfortable wasting rounds when I only have 5 or 10-11 total and the reload time with a speedloader or speed strip is considerably longer than a magazine change.
Well, hopefully I wouldn't be wasting rounds, I would be trying to put them into the shooter's chest. 5 rounds isn't a large ammo reserve, but I'm willing to sacrifice some ammo for portability. Most guys I see who buy Sig 220's or Glock 21's for off-duty carry stop carrying them very quickly. Mostly because they are too big for easy conceal carry.

When I go out in mild weather, I'm wearing short or jeans and T-shirt and the .38 is ideal for concealment under a untucked shirt. I used to own a Glock 26, and while I think it is an excellent pistol, I feel it is a little less comfortable to carry. In colder weather I like to carry a Colt Officer's Model in .45, but in colder weather you have the advantage of heavier clothing.

Opinions vary, but like you said, anything is better than nothing!



Posted by: Barbrady

Quote:
Originally Posted by Killjoy View Post
Most guys I see who buy Sig 220's or Glock 21's for off-duty carry stop carrying them very quickly. Mostly because they are too big for easy conceal carry.
I have to agree and it is why I carry my 232. I carried a G39 for awhile but it was uncomfortable. The P232 is perfect for me but I will agree that even with high velocity .380 its marginal.



Posted by: Delta784

Quote:
Originally Posted by Barbrady View Post
I have to agree and it is why I carry my 232. I carried a G39 for awhile but it was uncomfortable. The P232 is perfect for me but I will agree that even with high velocity .380 its marginal.
I'm always puzzled when people (cops) who wear a full duty belt for 8 & 16 hours at a time complain about carrying a subcompact pistol off-duty. My Glock 26 is barely larger & heavier than the S&W Model 60 it replaced, with a hell of a lot more firepower. I have a good molded IWB holster, and once I position it correctly I don't even feel it.



Posted by: Barbrady

I know I guess I am one of those odd ducks.. A duty belt does not bother me one bit. Now my dogs are barking after 12+ hours. But, when it comes to off duty with a gun digging into my side thats another story. Maybe I need a better IWB holster. Cheap is for me = Uncle Mikes.



Posted by: Delta784

Quote:
Originally Posted by Barbrady View Post
Cheap is for me = Uncle Mikes.
That explains it....the Milwaukee's Best of duty gear.



Posted by: Killjoy

Quote:
That explains it....the Milwaukee's Best of duty gear.
That is so true.

BTW, I hate IWB holsters...I use Desantis mini-scabbards or speed scabbards, depending on the model. Just a personal preference.



Posted by: Barbrady

Cmon atleast make it Milwaukee's Ice..lol, it goes with the mobile mansion that I am living in. Don't be hating the po'.



Posted by: justanotherparatrooper

Ive carried a Glock 23 in a IWB and belt by Mitch Rosen for 20 years on a mostly daily basis year round. Its comfortable and wears well and doesnt shift around. So far as I know hasnt been picked out as Ive never been asked for my ID or LTC.



Posted by: LA Copper

I guess I'm kinda weird too. I carry my duty gun, a 9mm Beretta off-duty. Give me the 16 rounds anytime. And if I know I'm going into the city, a spare magazine or two goes with me also. I've carried it off-duty since 1990 and it hasn't been a problem.



Posted by: USMCMP5811

Quote:
Originally Posted by Killjoy View Post
That is so true.

BTW, I hate IWB holsters...I use Desantis mini-scabbards or speed scabbards, depending on the model. Just a personal preference.

I'm with ya Kill, unfortunately, We are limited as to what we can have by Dept Regs as to the type of holster we can have for off duty carry. basicly, thats a choice between two diferant holsters.





ma police, boston ma police, massachusetts police, massachusetts police, mass state police, mass police, ma, mass, massachusetts, massachusetts, massachutes, massachusetts law, massachusetts polece, police, officer, police officer, cops, police gear, law enforcement, police duty gear, state police, sheriff, law, police supply, police agency directory, police agency, police department, traffic officer, police dept, state trooper, dispatcher, massachusetts county sheriff, massachusetts sheriff, massachusetts department of corrections, ma doc, doc, dept of corrections, police information, civil service, ma civil service, massachusetts crime, police training, police academy, ma police academy, massachusetts officers, masscop, masscops, mpa, bpa, ibpoa, police association, massachusetts police news, massachusetts crime news, mass most wanted, police career information, police patrol, police administration, police books, crime scene training, police discussion, crime discussions, cops

About MassCops, the home for Massachusetts law enforcement.

The Massachusetts Law Enforcement Network opened in 1998 and is now a part of the New England Police Network The site is a pro-police discussion forum intended for sworn police officers and civilian law enforcement officials as well as those interested in pursuing a career in law enforcement here in Massachusetts.

The goal of The Massachusetts Law Enforcement Network is to provide an informal network of law enforcement officials here in Massachusetts for educational and informational purposes.

The forum covers many topics such as Police Related News Articles, Agency & Profession Discussions, Police Training as well as Law Enforcement Career Information.

The Massachusetts Law Enforcement Network and The New England Police Network (NEPN) and it's network sites are privately owned websites/domains and are not affiliated with or endorsed by any government association or agency.

MassCops (masscops.com) and (masscop.com) are privately owned are not affiliated with or endorsed by the Massachusetts Coalition of Police (masscop.org)



vBulletin Copyright ©2000 - 2008, Jelsoft Enterprises Limited.
vB Easy Archive Final ©2000 - 2008 - Created by Stefan "Xenon" Kaeser

3 4 5 6 7 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 49 50 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 98 99 100 101 102 103 104 105 106 107 108